Guest Post by Katha Pollitt: The NBCC at 35

by Jane Ciabattari | Oct-02-2009


Former NBCC board member (and NBCC awardee in poetry for “Antarctic Traveller”) Katha Pollitt sends her reflections on “how the sausage is made” from Berlin.

I won the NBCC Award in Poetry in l982, and was elected to the board the following year.  The books my first year were terrific—I remember in particular Louise Erdrich’s “Love Medicine,”  Robert Darnton’s “The Great Cat Massacre,” Elinor Langer’s biography of Josephine Herbst. The discussions were both passionate and—- thanks to the unflappable Brigitte Weeks—civil. Well, mostly civil. The voluble and enthusiastic polymath Greil Marcus did have a way of bringing out the wild man in some usually mild literary gents. (“I used to admire you,” one such began ominously.  You can imagine where that sentence ended.)

One thing that struck me as a prize-panel neophyte was how often the award went to a compromise candidate—it was sometimes better to be the second or even third choice of lots of board members than the first choice of a smaller group, because the first choices attracted thunderbolts and knocked each other out.  Another eyeopener:  Critics who had no fear of evaluating books about Japanese literature, biology, law or obscure corners of history quailed when asked to grapple with even one slim volume of verse, let alone five of them.  As a poet, I found this depressing, although it did have the effect of magnifying the preferences of those of us who cared about the poetry category.

It was an interesting experience seeing how the sausage was made, and helping to make it myself.  But it did have the effect of making me wonder a little about my own NBCC award…

About the Critical Mass Blog

Commentary on literary criticism, publishing, writing, and all things NBCC related. It's written by independent members of the NBCC Board of Directors (see list of bloggers below).


Categories & Archives

Become a Member of the NBCC

NBCC Awards

Finalists for 2017

See all award winners

Find out how to submit

Read how we select

Frequently Asked Questions

Upcoming Events

NBCC Finalists’ Reading: March 13th, 2019

NBCC Awards Ceremony and Reception: March 14th, 2019

NBCC at AWP19 with Paul Beatty and Joan Silber: March 28th, 2019

NBCC at AWP19 The Future of Criticism: A Conversation with Established and Emerging Critics: March 30th, 2019

Videos and Podcasts

NBCC 2017 Awards Ceremony

NBCC 2017 Finalists Reading

All videos and podcasts.